November 1946

The mid-term elections were a disaster for H.A. and the progressive Democrats.  The Republicans two-word slogan “Had Enough?” captured the mood of the nation.  The slogan was also modified to include “Had enough strikes?” and “Had enough communism?”  Senator Robert Taft of Ohio accused the president of seeking a Congress “dominated by a policy of appeasing the Russians abroad and of fostering Communism at home.”  The Archbishop of New York, Francis Cardinal Spellman wrote an article prior to the election saying “only the bat-blind can fail to be aware of the Communist invasion of our country.”  The U.S. Chamber of Commerce widely distributed a report entitled “Communist Infiltration in the United States.” 

The voters gave the Republicans control of both houses of Congress for the first time since 1928.  The Republicans now have a 58-seat majority in the House (246 to 188 -AS) and a six-seat edge in the Senate.  However, the actual loss for H.A. is even higher when you consider that the vast majority of the Southern delegation is also hostile to H.A.  Many Republican elected officials are talking of leaving the Democratic Party to be more closely associated with the Whiskey Rebel controlled Republicans.  I guess their hatred of Communists exceeds their hatred of the party of Lincoln.  Two rabid anti-communists are going to be taking seats in Congress.  Senator Joseph McCarthy of Wisconsin and Representative Richard Nixon of California both of whom obtained their seats by smearing their opponents as pinkos and communists.  Nixon defeated Congressman Jerry Voorhis by linking him to the “Moscow-CIO PAC-Henry Wallace line.” 

H.A. responded by saying that “As a result of this election, the Democratic Party will either become more progressive or it will die.  I do not expect it to die.”  He added, “The American people have rejected, as they will always reject, a Democratic Party that is not militantly progressive… Of course, we need organization.  The primary effort of progressives may be to rebuild the Democratic Party as a liberal party.” 

In response the red-baiting of the Republicans, conservative Democrats and Whiskey Rebels, H.A. said, “We shall hold firmly to the American theme of peace, prosperity and freedom and shall repel all the attacks of the plutocrats and monopolists who will try to brand us as reds.  If it is traitorous to believe in peace, we are traitors.  If it is communistic to believe in prosperity for all, we are communists.  If it is red-baiting to fight for free speech and real freedom of the press, we are red-baiters.  If it is un-American to believe in freedom from monopolistic dictation, we are un-American.  I say that we are more American than the neo-Fascists who attack us.  I say on with the fight.”

In response to subsequent attacks, H.A. said, “Those who put hatred of Russia first in all their feelings and actions do not believe in peace.  We shall never be against anything simply because Russia is for it.  Neither shall we ever be for anything simply because Russia is for it.  We shall hold firmly to the American theme of peace, prosperity and freedom.”

Needless to say the Whiskey Rebels and other opponents used this language to confirm their rhetoric of fear and hate.  To further drum up the fears of Communism, J. Edgar Hoover at a speech before the American Legion charged that at least 100,000 Communists were loose in the nation’s schools, colleges, churches, newspapers, movie studios, and radio stations.

H.A. had dealt with this type of fear mongering before.  Texas Congressman Martin Dies, an ultra-conservative and chairman of the House Special Committee on Un-American Activities, wrote a letter to H.A. on March 28, 1942, which he gave to reporters the next day, charging that “at least thirty-five high government officials employed by the Board of Economic Warfare have public records which show affiliations with front organizations of the Community Party.”  H.A. hit back immediately and strongly.  In a four-page rebuttal H.A. accused Dies of seeking “to inflame the public mind by a malicious distortion of the facts.”  Citing the need for unity in our war effort, H.A. said, “the doubts and anger which this and similar statements of Mr. Dies tend to arouse in the public mind might as well come from [Nazi propagandist Joseph -AS] Goebbels himself as far as their practical effect is concerned.”  The newspapers, and the public, saw this as yet another attempt by Dies to promote himself at the expense of others and then sided with the Vice President.

This election is a clear indication that public option is turning away from H.A.  I hope he can stem the tide and return the electorate to the sanity of progressive Democrats. Also, I hope H.A. sees that it is time to fire that fascist Hoover!

©  2013 Ron Millar